(Scroll down to the bottom to see the resume this post is about)
I feel like a secret shopper.
This week I’ve been in the process of uploading myself onto different job boards, in hopes of finding more opportunities within my field. One of those websites I signed up with sounded familiar, but it wasn’t until I was half-way finished with my profile that I remembered why.
The resume writing company I work for has a deal with them.
That statement may sound like a shady, back-alley kind of thing.
It absolutely is.
When I first signed up with the website they sent me an email announcing their free resume critiques. I opted out, because I’ve read those critiques before, from clients who purchased our services after receiving one. Being a professional resume writer, I’m confident in my abilities, and while I’m fully aware that there’s always room for growth, I don’t need an automated critique to tell me how I should go about it.
The next morning, I woke up to another email, informing me that my free critique is available to view.
Already annoyed, I opened the link and found the (generic) critique that had been “custom” created for my resume. Immediately there were some glaring issues. It told me I didn’t have an objective statement, which I don’t, because those are antiquated and unnecessary. But it then went on to define an objective statement as a career summary, which gives an overview of your experience before getting to the meat of the resume. I do have one of those. A full paragraph, right at the top of the resume. Not off to a great start, Mr. Resume Critique Bot.
The next big problem is a little more nuanced. The critique informed me that my resume is skills based rather than achievement based. In some respects, this is true. The resume I uploaded doesn’t have the spiffy kind of businessy achievements resume websites will use as examples—
“Slashed costs 70%”
“Saved employer 2.3 million dollars”
“Streamlined processes”
Contrary to what the good folks at Fake Resume Critique R US will have you believe, achievements are NOT always that straightforward. They don’t always follow the cookie cutter algorithm of responsibility + effort = result that we’re told to use when writing bullets. The resume of mine that Resume Snobs Inc. so graciously critiqued was intentionally written to give an over view of my writing specializations, a few projects I’ve completed, and my relevant work experience. It’s a non-standard structure, which apparently the Critique Bot could not understand.
The point of this little rant isn’t just to vent about the woes of working for an industry filled with scams and false information. Since starting this blog entry I continued to receive messages from the website in question, offering me a great discount (15%) for a brand-new, $165 resume.
Right now I’m the customer, so all I see is the awful rating my resume received, and the heavy-handed call to purchase a new one. Normally though, I would be the writer who works with the poor fool who believed that scare tactic.
It works like this:
- The website scans your resume, and offers a “custom” critique that’s really more like one of those fill in the blank stories. Every critique is more or less the same.
- Good Guy Job Site offers to rewrite your resume, giving a brief overview of the services you’d receive, how much you’d pay, and why you should do it.
- After purchasing services, the critique and the resume are given to a writer (me), who will get paid about $20 of that $165 to create a new resume.
- Job Website and Resume Website celebrate their mutual genius while the poor writer scrambles to comfort a distressed client who has buyer’s remorse.
- The client ends up happy, or screwed over by an incompetent writer.
Looking for a job is a job in itself, they say. And in my case, that is apparently literal. Having spent two years working for a company that now has a monopoly on online resume writing services, I now find myself knowingly signing up for those very websites that scam unsuspecting, desperate job seekers into purchasing assistance they may or may not need.
The moral of the story:
When you are job searching, you may have no choice but to rely on some of those job sites out there. They’re wonderful tools for finding open positions and making yourself visible as a professional. HOWEVER. Many of these sites offer “services” that are misrepresented and overpriced. In this case, upon ordering the suggested resume makeover, your information would be sent into a random lottery of writers—all with different skill levels and backgrounds. You could end up with a trained writer like me…or the fate of your $165 new resume could land in the hands of someone who took a creative writing class once back in college, and kind of knows how to string words together to form a sentence.
Having a resume professionally done is a great way of improving your chances of getting a new job. But regardless of how legitimate the many hundreds of job posting sites out there may be, if you don’t see the name of the writer, or their credentials, don’t purchase the services.
With the unstable job market, the resume writing industry is booming. It’s also not regulated, so one website might charge you $99, and another might charge $300 for the exact same service.
Do your research. Preferably, go with an independent writer who is up front about their background, their training, and the services you will receive. If you DO go through a company, read reviews.
More than anything, trust the feedback of real people over that of an automated job site robot. Show your current resume to an employer, your coworkers, friends, etc. Ask them what they think.
If you receive negative feedback, some independent resume writers (like myself) will give you free, or affordable critiques that are actually customized. Before purchasing that service make sure you know what you’ll be getting. Ask what they will critique, and don’t be afraid to ask if it will be a critique that is specifically written based on your resume, and not a form letter with a few blank spaces filled out.
tl;dr—Online job sites will try to coerce you into buying overpriced resume re-writes. Seek out an independent, experienced writer instead. Don’t be a consumerism sheep.
Boring information about my services: The critiques I write are $15, and include an analysis of the content, wording, spelling and grammar, structure, organization, and visual appeal of your current resume. There are no strings attached, and no pressure to purchase a re-write. If you decide to order a new resume after reading the critique, you’ll receive a completely overhauled document, as well as a cover letter. The $15 from the critique is applied to the final cost of the resume, leaving it at $85. This is my standard rate, critique or no, so you basically end up getting the critique for free.
You can see the resume that started it all here.